May 31, 2020

16.02.11: The Tyche Files.

Something kept floating around our astro-radar yesterday as we busily wrote about comet flybys, launches, and wacky space weather. Titles like “New Solar System Planet!” and “Solar Companion Found!” kept making a spurious appearance from unverified sources.

I’m always suspicious of proclamations with exclamation points, as my spam folder is full of them. The traditional sources were mum about the whole affair… what’s up? I then did some late night research and discovered the whole online stir is yet another “non-troversy” in the spirit of the Betelgeuse supernova and the 13th zodiacal sign. Yes, there is some interesting science to the whole affair, and a good “teachable moment,” but old school media never lets reality get in the way of a good story…

The whole affair has its roots way back in the search for Planet X. Way back in the early days of planet hunting, it was found that you could predict the location of a new world by its gravitational tug. Lavoisier, a theoretical mathematician who distained actually looking through a telescope, discovered Neptune this way. A later search initiated by Percival Lowell turned up the ever controversial planet Pluto, discovered by Clyde Tombaugh in 1930.

Fast forward to the modern day era, a brave new solar system of Oort Clouds, Plutoids, and Kuiper Belt Objects. In 1999, astronomers John Matese and Daniel Whitmire from the University of Louisiana made a proposal that a massive but undiscovered object resides in the Oort Cloud. The claim is based on projected groupings of comet swarms along the ecliptic. One would expect long period comets to come into the inner solar system from more or less random directions and intervals; instead, a distinctive clustering over time is observed, one that might be predicted by the existence of a distant Jupiter mass object… and thus the hypothetical world of Tyche was born. The “planet” was christened rather appropriately after the Greek demigoddess of “luck” as an antithesis of Nemesis, another distant hypothetical world. What’s curious is that Matese and Whitmire actually give rough positional perimeters for Tyche in last years’ submission to the journal Icarus. A body such as Tyche would orbit at a distance equivalent to about 15,000 astronomical units (A.U.) once every 1.8 million years (!) For some sense of scale, Pluto orbits about 40 A.U., and the Oort Cloud reservoir of comets is predicted to extend from about 5,000 to 50,000 A.U. Scans through the old IRAS data limit any distant body larger than 5 Jupiter masses to a distance of >10,000 A.U.

So, why the fuss now? Well, the WISE (Wide Field Infrared Survey Explorer) team will release the first portion of its infrared all sky survey as part of its follow-up NEOWISE mission this April, and the thinking is that a possibility exists that a distant 1-4 Jupiter mass body might just reveal itself… But let’s just state right now that this is a long shot. A solar system body larger than Jupiter would be big news, yes, but it’s far from proven. As noted by astronomer Mike Brown on his blog, some odd things are going on in the outer solar system, most notably concerning the wacky orbit of the dwarf planet Sedna. The whole concept sounds vaguely like the Nemesis hypothesis revisited; that our solar system has a large dark companion, such as a black/brown dwarf or even something more exotic like a black hole. Not that the last one is at all likely; I think we’d be seeing the x-ray high energy anomalies by now. A red dwarf or even a brown dwarf companion is remote as well; at about 13 Jupiter masses low grade deuterium fusion begins to occur and you would have a brown dwarf visible to spacecraft like WISE in the infrared wavelengths. Anyhow, this story has gotten new life by a recent article in The Independent, conspiracy sites are already abuzz about an even more fictional world named Nibiru that is supposed to rain death and destruction in 2012, and well, you get the idea; a perfect storm for a new doomsday non-troversy that the media seems so intent on perpetrating. Hey, it puts eyeballs on web-pages, in this cyber-hit driven world. (We couldn’t resist blogging about it!) It is fascinating to think of what might be out there, and that our solar system may not be as well known as we thought. It’s just a very long shot that something on an extremely long hypothetical orbit like Tyche would reveal itself this year. Ancient stellar passages may be just as likely culprit in braiding our Oort Cloud. Doubtless, this will become news again in April when the NEOWISE data is released, and scientists and amateurs alike will be scouring it for anything amiss… if nothing else, we’ll probably find lots of new asteroids and comets in the process. Will Tyche become reality, or is it destined to join the long list of Vulcans, Neiths, Liliths, (Look em up!) and Nemeses in the dust bin of solar system objects? Stay tuned!


  1. Galwin says:

    I am searching for preferably a online site that would allow me ot see the actual orbits of projected astral bodies, astroids and such within the parameters of our solar system. I see a lot of various videos on youtube and such which people seem to have “Seem at least” such a site as it will show like comets their projected orbits, distances from eash planet as it passes through our system and such. Any ideas or sugestions? I figure with all the crap hype out there the only way to get any serious info is to go to the source, checked NASA stuff but either did not know what I was looking for or was not there. I am no conspiracy nut nor doomsday follower. However one must still keep an open mind, I like to plan for the worst, pray and hope for the best, so IF anything did occur I would hopefully come out somewhere in the middle. Best, Galwin

  2. David Dickinson says:

    For newly discovered objects, I prefer to use Starry Night to plug in orbital elements. This takes a little knowledge of orbital charactistics and interpretation, and works offline on your desktop. The online animations your probably seeing are the JPL Small Body database Browser such as this graphic for Sedna: Very interesting to play with.


  1. [...] In 1979, Carl Sagan proposed that the information might have been given to the Dogon by an external source, albeit a terrestrial one. Keep in mind, the legend coming to light in the 20th century wasn’t really giving us any new information about Sirius; psychics perform this feat all the time when they claim to have predicted events that have already happened. When we look at ancient myths and lore, we need to be mindful of the creativity of the human mind; after all, what would archaeologists thousands of years from now make of a Star Trek episode? That we somehow had warp drive and phaser technology? A true myth having some sort of predictive power would be far more compelling. Does this mean that the discovery of a red dwarf star around Sirius, as was spuriously reported in the 1990’s, would lend some credence to the tale? While interesting, I don’t necessarily believe so, as red/brown dwarf stars are quite common in the cosmos; for example, it’s not totally ruled out that our own sun may have a dim unseen companion! [...]

  2. [...] and leaves the idea of a hypothetical remote gas giant in the extreme outer solar system known as Tyche, only slightly more tenable. And of course, the conspiracy mongers hoping to resurrect Nibiru need [...]

  3. [...] good reason to believe something(s?) out there shepherding these Senitos into a similar orbit with a comparable argument of perihelion. [...]

  4. [...] good reason to trust something(s?) out there shepherding these Senitos into a identical circuit with a allied evidence of perihelion. [...]

  5. [...] good reason to believe something(s?) out there shepherding these Senitos into a similar orbit with a comparable argument of perihelion. [...]

Speak Your Mind